I've been watching the live-stream today of Schlep and others testifying against Roblox in court, and it's left me with a pit in my stomach. Mostly because what everyone is suggesting is a threat to online privacy for everyone on the internet.

It's no secret that lately, more and more governments and businesses are pushing for online age verification under the guise of "protecting children". Obviously that is not their main goal, but it is a real problem that is being felt on platforms like Roblox. Without any safeguards at all, you do in fact face problems with users doing problematic things and preying on children. However, that does not mean they are currently going about it the right way.

The Online Safety Dilemma: Privacy vs Safety

I can see where defenders of age verification are coming from, I really do. It's not like it's a wholly terrible idea in a perfect world. Notice though, how I said "in a perfect world". Matter of fact, we don't and that's a problem.

The reality is that there are some serious problems that age verification addresses.

  1. 1.

    You can neatly understand who is of age for certain things and who isn't.

  2. 2.

    You can verify that people are telling the truth when they sign up for your website.

  3. 3.

    You can restrict access to more problematic things for people who shouldn't see them (i.e. children).

The only problem with this is that it assumes that whoever you're verifying with can be trusted. In an ideal situation, whoever you are verifying with will only keep the data they need, and only keep it to themselves. The ideal that they keep your privacy intact.

With the world we live in right now with all the big companies making money off of your data, there is simply too much eroded trust for us to trust that they will, in fact, respect our privacy because they already don't. And with something as sensitive as an ID, you know they are keeping that to sell to whoever is willing to buy. Because you're information is valuable.

Thus, in pursuit of safety you erode privacy. And it seems that in order to maintain privacy, safety must be eroded.

In all honesty, this is a dilemma with no proper answer. No answer that will 100% satisfy both sides here. However, I think there is a way to meet in the middle.

Unverify: The proposal

I've had this idea for a while for age verification that respects privacy. It sounds impossible, I know. It's really more difficult than anything.

I'm a huge advocate for online privacy. The web is a place unlike any other in the fact that it leaves you free to say and do pretty much whatever you want (with some very valid exceptions). I don't ever want the web to stop being that way, and having privacy online is the only way it can stay that way. However I can't deny the real issues that such freedom does entail.

The idea behind Unverify is simple: transparency. To make the most transparent and privacy-respecting verification provider possible. Here's the basic idea of how:

  1. 1.

    Privacy policy that clearly states intent. Privacy policies are legal agreements that the people who run a service must follow. In the privacy policy, state that no data is retained that is not required, specifically that images involving ID are discarded as soon as it is processed. Non-important data that won't be kept involves name, location, phone number, gender, race, and any other considerably identifiable information.

  2. 2.

    Abide by double anonymity. The verification provider will not know what you're signing up for, and the thing you are verifying for will not know anything more than what they need to know. This could perhaps by accomplished be generating some unique "token" that anyone who verifies is given. Said token can be verified by the service seeking verification and contains only the date of birth of the person trying to verify. In simpler terms, you are given a string of characters that you can provide to any service seeking verification that will securely tell them your birthday and verify that you have verified your age.

  3. 3.

    Code for the entirety of the verification provider must be open-source (save for parts that can't be under law). To continue with the idea of transparency, the verification provider must retain open and readable source code that can be browsed (and perhaps contributed to) by the general public. This ensures that nothing can be snuck in that will compromise user privacy.

The idea is that the provider only holds onto data as long as it needs to before discarding it permanently without storing it. That is especially the whole inspiration for the "age verification token", the idea that maybe on the whole that they don't need to store anything at all. That you get this cryptographically secure string that you can provide to anyone asking for verification and provide a legitimate, verifiable source of information for nothing but your date of birth and age at verification time.

Conclusion

I know this isn't super long, but this idea has been floating around in my head for a really long time and now is as good a time as ever to actually write about it and post it online. I don't want age verification, but every single day it seems like we need it. However we cannot put our trust in companies like Persona, who have decidedly selfish goals in mind when it comes to age verification. Companies who actively benefit from taking your data and selling it to others including the government.

At the end of the day though, I'm only eighteen. I'm sure there are plenty of flaws with this proposal, and I'm nowhere near an expert, but I still have my two cents to give regardless. Not to mention that the laws being passed about all this are from a disingenuous place to begin with. The reality is that the laws are trying to move things towards surveillance, using the idea of "child safety" as a crutch to do so without actually fixing that problem.

Unverify is my idea to actually fix the problem without surveillance.

Anyway, I'd like to hear your thoughts. Feel free to comment them wherever you feel like.